Plesk not adding SSL to Windows2003/iis6 for one domain

[jtroher]

I have Plesk 8.6 for Windows (2003 with IIS6) and have a domain that has an existing SSL that is working fine currently. I have renewed the SSL successfully and have the certificate installed in Plesk fine, and set the domain to use the new SSL, but pulling the site up in a browser still shows the old one. When I go into Windows it does not even show the new SSL at all. I even tried disabling SSL from the site altogether but it is not going through into Windows. Anyone have any ideas?

*Added note* this is only affecting one domain. All other domains on the server aren't having this issue.