Hi Igor,
I took a look at the link you sent me.
How can I check if SNI is switched on in Plesk?
Also, I see that it says the following in the article but after I check on "Enable SSL support" for my domain. When I go back to the "SSL certificate" menu it doesn't give me an option to select the SSL and click OK. It only shows the SSL that I created before but it doesn't seem to be linked to my domain name because when I go to the website the SSL doesn't seem to be working.
15.To install the certificate on a site, return to the Websites & Domains tab, and click the domain name of the website that you want to to secure.
16.To switch on SSL protection, select the Enable SSL support checkbox.
17.From the SSL certificate menu, select your SSL certificate and click OK.
I'm on a shared IP, and based on your response I should be able to have multiple SSLs for a shared IP addres using SNI but it doesn't seem to be working. Is there anything else I can try doing?
Thank you!