Control Panel won't use Default Certificate

[lesfenison]

I just added an SSL certificate for one of my domains and it is working great but...

Now, anyone from the other domains attempting to use the Plesk control panel gets the new cert! The new cert is the only cert ever purchased for this server so, I just assumed that now I have to purchase yet another cert for everyone else. So I did, no luck. Still everyone uses the first cert. Does anyone know how to fix this??

 

[DWPal]

I'm fairly sure you can only have one registered SSL cert per IP address.