Default Certificate Error

[alirizvi55]

After I installed a new cert on one of my domains, I still got the default plesk cert at:
https://www.domain.com

The new cert seemed to have installed just fine but then I noticed that I couldn't open the default certificate in Plesk. I get the following error:
CertEditForm::assign() failed: Unable to get certificate info: openssl_x509_parse() failed: error:0906D06CEM routines:func(109):reason(108)error:0906D06CEM routines:func(109):reason(108)
0: /usr/local/psa/admin/htdocs/cert/cert_edit.php:278 psaerror(string "CertEditForm::assign() failed: Unable to get certificate info: openssl_x509_parse() failed: error:0906D06CEM routines:func(109):reason(108)error:0906D06CEM routines:func(109):reason(108)")

Anyone have ideas on what could have gone wrong?

Thanks,
Ali