Yes, the condition was correct, its the notice that we took issue with. The customer's knew already that the site was not published, and took offense that we are emailing them to tell them something they already know. By default, we do not hound our customers with any kind of marketing emails, so this struck a sore spot with the ones that got these notices. By default when we setup servers we turn Plesk customer notifications of for 99% of the items it would notify them about, but this one notice was added in an update, and slipped past us. Hence my suggestion to add these notifications with a default of "off" and allow us to make that choice.